A brief rebuttal to borg and the jesus seminar by robert p. The gospel of jesus is a single composite gospel created out of the sayings and reports that were deemed probably historical by the jesus seminar. Frontline, the longrunning pbs documentary film series, will kick off holy week with two evenings of a reimagined jesus and a deconstructed early church, titled from jesus to christ, the first christians. Held by invitation in churches, schools and convention centers, each event includes lectures and workshops on a wide range of topics. The jesus seminar started with 30 scholars at the initial meeting and grew to more than 200 specialists, called fellows, who participated in various phases from 1985 1998. Courting the media at the cost of truth by james r. In 1985 a group of new testament scholars gathered to vote on the authenticity of the sayings of jesus. It is not the theological fantasy upon which the jesus seminar thrives. Chong spring, 2003 in march 1985, a group of scholars convened in berkeley, california, for the. But in fact it presents a perception of jesus which is seculardriven with a hidden agenda to belittle christianity. A group of selfproclaimed scholars, called the jesus society, were behind the stories.
Frontlines films are conceived and developed by david fanning whoas laurence. Recently june 26, 2000, abc news presented a special twohour television program titled, in search of jesus, with popular broadcaster peter jennings as host. Over the next five or six years the panel will evaluate the approximately 500 sayings attributed to jesus. Some personal reflections on the jesus seminar asbury. Pdf about our mission board of directors westar fellows our research our members ways to give get involved become a member become a westar fellow. It is a relatively new corporate venture that attempts, by a process of discussion and voting, to arrive at an answer to two questions. These scholars claim to work out, with varying degrees of probability, which are which. Pdf five gospels funk download full pdf book download. Leading scholarsfellows of the jesus seminar have decided to update and then make the legacy of two. Of making many books there is no end this saying from ecclesiastes could also describe the. Seminar rules out 80% of words attributed to jesus. A roman catholic monk for nineteen years and a priest for twelve years, crossan is a former cochair of the jesus seminar and chair of the historical jesus section of the society of biblical literature. The jesus seminar was a group of scholars founded in 1985 by robert w.
Robert funk, professor of religious studies at the university of montana. The jesus seminar was a group of about 50 critical biblical scholars and 100 laymen founded in 1985 by robert funk that originated under the auspices of the westar institute. The jesus seminar on the road brings fellows of the jesus seminar into conversation with interested people across north america and around the world. In 1985 the jesus seminar, comprising a distinguished group of biblical scholars, was founded by. Jun 18, 2004 crossan was cochair of the jesus seminar from 19851996 and as chair of the historical jesus section of the society of biblical literature from 19921998. Funk, the jesus seminar has become a lightning rod for international debate about the historical jesus that is, the real facts about the person to whom various. As a result, headlines proclaiming that scholars have discovered that jesus never said hed. Westar institute home of the jesus seminar is dedicated to fostering and communicating the results of cuttingedge scholarship on the history and evolution of the christian tradition, thereby raising the level of public discourse about questions that matter in society and culture. Overall, the jesus seminar is composed of protestants, catholics, and atheists, professors at universities and seminaries, one pastor, three members of the westar institute in california which sponsored the project, one filmmaker, and three others whose current occupations are entirely unidentified. The jesus seminar is a group of around 150 people, including scholars, who meet to discuss the historical jesus. This is a great question, and im afraid i dont know the definitive answer in part because the jesus seminar did not have one and only one view on many topics. Please feel free to call us at 1800my faith 6932484 or email us with any further questions on this or any other subject. The very titlethe jesus seminar sounds very official, like it is a modern day council of nicea, or a twentieth century council of trent as men of god come together and say, this is what god is saying today.
It preceded the shortlived jesus project, which was active. There have been as many as 200 scholars participating in the jesus seminar over the years, but the final group is now 74. The jesus seminar based its examination on the presupposition, the evangelists frequently attribute their own statements to jesus. The jesus seminar revealed 5 of 32 because we are professionals and because the issue of jesus is there to be faced, much as mt. The scholars who became part of the jesus seminar hold to the mentality of bultmann and the existentialists, examining new testament statements, then voting on whether or not they are factual. Warfield who many years ago wrote, and in general, no form of criticism is more uncertain than that, now so diligently prosecuted, which seeks to explain the several forms of. In the gospel of jesus, robert funk and the jesus seminar take the work of popularizing historical jesus studies in a new and exciting direction.
The jesus seminar and john the baptist the bart ehrman blog. Although never formally disbanded, it effectively ceased functioning as the jesus seminar in 2006, shortly after the 2005 death of its founder, robert funk. In their attempt to rescue the bible from in the jesus. Funk at the launch of the jesus seminar in march 1985 in berkeley, california. While the program touted itself as an objective investigation into the nature of the jesus of history, it was really little more than a propaganda piece for the radical assertions of the selfproclaimed jesus seminar. See more ideas about old things, happy sabbath and blessed assurance. The quest for the historical jesus has been too long captivated by the willothewisp of a historical jesus, an objective artifactual figure buried in the gospels and waiting to be exhumed and brandished aloft, as different from the jesus of the gospels not fully realizing that the less the reconstructed jesus owed to the synoptic. Jun 09, 2009 the jesus seminar is a small group of extremely liberal scholars. Funk, architect and founder of the jesus seminar, in a keynote address to the jesus seminar fellows in the spring of 1994. Jul 21, 2015 the scholars who became part of the jesus seminar hold to the mentality of bultmann and the existentialists, examining new testament statements, then voting on whether or not they are factual. Apr 01, 2017 the jesus seminar was very active through the 1980s and 1990s, and into the early 21st century. The jesus seminar was very active through the 1980s and 1990s, and into the early 21st century. A book published by some of the men entitled the five gospels explained how they came to the conclusion that only 18% of the words attributed to jesus.
Warfield who many years ago wrote, and in general, no form of criticism is more uncertain than that, now so diligently prosecuted, which. Does the jesus seminar also reject the claim that the baptist was an apocalypticist. Jesus did not regard scripture as infallible or even inspired. M arcus borg and the jesus seminar challenge us to respond to the question jesus posed to peter. The jesus seminar produced a significant number of publications both in the form of journal. Before sketching the answer that gospel specialists in the jesus seminar give. Viewpoint the jesus seminar and the gospel of thomas. The fellows of the jesus seminar seem to think that the witness of the gospels writers cannot be accepted behe jesus seminar is not so much a work of scholarship as a tract for the times. In this new phase, fellows of the jesus seminar on christian origins employ the methods and techniques pioneered by the original jesus seminar. The seminar employed colored beads dropped into voting boxes in order to permit all members to vote in secret. Over the next five years, the jesus seminar, as the group came to be known, met twice a year to vote on over 1,500 versions of 518 sayings.
The five gospels answers these questions in a bold, dynamic work that will startle traditional readers of the bible and rekindle interest in it among secular skeptics. Starting with about 30, and sometimes having as many as 150 people involved, the seminar covered three different areas of jesus recorded history. Schmidt, james a veitch, john white, bernard brandon scott on. While presenting itself as scholarly, it appears to be becoming more and more populist with enthusiastic support coming from scepticsatheists and all the more liberal and. Profiles of jesus 2002 offers a variety of synthetic attempts to detect what a profile of the historical jesus could be. Excerpt from opening remarks of jesus seminar and westar institute founder robert w. Thirty scholars participated in the first meeting and approximately 200 people now call themselves fellows. I will take only a few presuppositions of the jesus seminar because a posting going through every presupposition would be much too large for this or any newsgroup. They meet and vote with colored beads to decide which sayings of jesus are authentic and which are not. The jesus seminar has begun a dramatic alteration of the documents which compose the new testament. Our local church has introduced material from this organisation and i am unable to find anyone in the uk who has used it before. Beads and boxes turned out to be a fortunate choice for both the fellows and any of the public who were interested.
At the beginning of april, 1996, three major news magazines times, newsweek, and us news and world report all carried the same lead story the search for the historical jesus a. No doubt there are at least as many opinions about the the jesus seminar as the. What does mainstream scholarship think about the conclusions of the jesus seminar. Rediscovering the apostle paul jesus seminar guides vol 5 gerd ludemann, heikki raisanen, daryl d. Pages in category members of the jesus seminar the following 11 pages are in this category, out of 11 total. Rediscovering the apostle paul jesus seminar guides vol 5. The jesus seminar claims that some of the words of jesus recorded in the gospels were actually said by him but others were invented by the early church or the writers of the gospels. The following is a short rebuttal to the responses of the jesus seminar. Crossan was cochair of the jesus seminar from 19851996 and as chair of the historical jesus section of the society of biblical literature from 19921998. The jesus seminar was a group of about 50 critical biblical scholars and 100 laymen founded. This single composite gospel is created out of the stories told about and words ascribed to jesus in the ancient gospels. Box 8500, charlotte, nc 28271 phone 704 8878200 and fax 704 8878299 2 with the release of the five gospels in 1993, the jesus seminar helped propel the secondcentury gospel of thomas into the forefront of media attention.
Pbs is observing the easter season with hours of theological toxin aimed directly at orthodox christianity. In 1985 the jesus seminar, comprising a distinguished group of biblical scholars, was founded by robert w. The jesus seminar was created to examine the biblical gospels and other early christian literature to discover who jesus truly was and what he truly said. The historical jesus, and excavating jesus a groundbreaking study on jesus cowritten with archeologist jonathan reed. Apr 01, 2009 this is from our series the search or jesus continues. General topics the jesus seminar the jesus seminar posted by terrybob, on. The seminar was very active through the 1980s and 1990s, and into the early 21st century. In this first part of a twopart article, the presuppositions and pretentions of the jesus seminar are exposited and assessed. Jesus did not ask us to believe that he was born of a virgin. We are going to inquire simply, rigorously after the voice of jesus, after what he really said. If you had any remaining questions about the methods, goals, and origins of the notorious jesus seminar, this book by my seminar colleague and pal bob miller ought to put them to rest. The seminar suggests the high christology of jesushis messianic claims, the miracles, the substitutionary atonement, the resurrectionall were added later by a persecuted church in need of a powerful god when in fact the real jesus was just a pleasant peasant who somehow managed to get himself crucified. Jesus said, look, i will guide her to make her male, so that she too may become a living spirit resembling you males.
Jan 02, 2020 the jesus seminar was created to examine the biblical gospels and other early christian literature to discover who jesus truly was and what he truly said. The jesus seminar was and still is comprised almost entirely of individuals who deny the inspiration, authority, and inerrancy of the bible. Gospel of jesus according to the jesus seminar westar institute. Readers should therefore not read the gospels as historical accounts of his.
The fact is that these individuals are selfappointed and do not represent historical churches or institutions of any kind. The popular impact of the jesus seminar was based largely upon the image, one might be tempted to say the myth, of the seminar as a group of unbiased scholars who carefully sifted the. One night the lord very definitely spoke to me, as i was ministering to people in the healing line, about teaching a seminar on the name of jesus. Recent articles alpha index surprise me author index. In march 2006, the jesus seminar began work on a new description of the emergence of the jesus traditions through the first two centuries of the common era ce. The jesus seminar westar institute westar institute. This volume is a product of the ultraliberal jesus seminar which has received so much undeserved publicity in recent years. Their views are not in the majority among critical scholars, but it is worth noting that they see jesus as. They initially focused on the sayings of jesus within the four gospels to determine the probability of his actually having said the things attributed to him in matthew. They are composed of members with protestant, catholic, jewish and independent backgrounds. It was founded in 1985 by the late robert funk and john dominic crossan. The jesus seminar is a group of academic theologians who study christian writings from the 1 st to 3 rd century ce, from a religiously liberal perspective.
Westar institute home of the jesus seminar is dedicated to fostering and communicating the results of cuttingedge scholarship on the history and evoluti. The acts of jesus 1998 delivers the seminar s report on the deeds and events in the life of jesus. Jul 22, 2015 the very titlethe jesus seminarsounds very official, like it is a modern day council of nicea, or a twentieth century council of trent as men of god come together and say, this is what god is saying today. Jesus seminar 1 jesus seminar john dominic crossan, noted member of the jesus seminar the jesus seminar was a group of about 150 critical scholars and laymen founded in 1985 by robert funk under the auspices of the westar institute. Christian scriptures new testament the jesus seminar. Nothing is clearer than the fact that the devotees of the jesus seminar have an infidelic agenda to pursue, and historical evidence means nothing to them. Historical jesus scholarship and christians the bart. Jesus seminar the jesus seminar is a controversial research team of academic new testament scholars founded in 1985 by the late robert funk under the auspices of the westar institute. Some background the jesus seminar was originally formed in 1985 under the sponsorship of the westar institute to renew the quest of the historical jesus.
The five gospels 1993 documents the first phase of the seminar on the sayings of jesus. White simon peter said to them, make mary leave us, for females dont deserve life. The jesus seminar in retrospect bill peddies website. First, there are a number of historical jesus scholars who do not see jesus in this way most prominently, members of the jesus seminar, such as marcus borg and john dominic crossan.
Liberal theologians investigating the life of jesus. In an incredibly arrogant assertion, robert funk, head of the seminars westar institute in sonoma, california charges that the christian movement hasnt seriously examined the question of canon since the 15th century sheler 1993, 75. In february 1978,i taught our annual prayer seminar at rhema bible training center in tulsa. The jesus seminar is taken seriously in some quarters. Evangelical responses to the jesus seminar 77 acceptance of the same historicalcritical assumptions, they have rejected the wisdom of b. Jesus seminar fellows, about 18 percent of the sayings and 16 percent of the deeds attributed to jesus in the gospels are authentic. The provocative jesus seminar on sunday concluded six years of voting on what the jesus of history most likely said, ruling out about 80% of words attributed to him in the gospels and emerging.
The jesus seminar is a panel of liberal theologians who have commissioned themselves for a cutandpaste job on the text of the new testament. The jesus seminar is a panel of new testament scholars whose chairman is dr. Leading scholarsfellows of the jesus seminar have decided to update and then make the legacy of two hundred years of research and debate a matter of public record. In the secondcentury christian manual known as the didache. By the time the magazine revisited the question for a 1996 cover story, a controversial group called the jesus seminar was leading the charge to.
909 678 202 1554 355 345 627 674 955 844 256 418 1012 760 977 1588 415 344 956 92 1611 801 80 582 194 590 227 1035 1397 1246 1326 699